The first question to ask when selecting a membrane system is, what needs to be filtered out of the water? The treatment methods for suspended solids, microorganisms, dissolved salts, and seawater salinity are different. This is why UF, RO, BWRO, and SWRO should NOT be considered as interchangeable technologies.
The list of water treatment system suppliers can be misleading for anyone who is comparing one to another. The ultrafiltration (UF) and reverse osmosis (RO) processes are different membrane processes, and brackish water reverse osmosis (BWRO) and seawater reverse osmosis (SWRO) are different types of RO processes based on different feed-water salinities. It is essential to have a raw-water analysis in order to choose membranes, pumps, pretreatment, or any recovery targets with a competent water treatment system manufacturer. In many projects, the Custom Water Treatment System may employ more than one stage of membranes.
The technologies vary primarily in what they separate, in the pressure needed and the feed water they can process.
|
Technology |
Main Function |
Dissolved Salt Removal |
Relative Pressure |
Typical Use |
|
UF |
Removes suspended solids, colloids, and many microorganisms |
No |
Low |
Wastewater treatment systems include surface water treatment, pretreatment, and wastewater polishing. |
|
RO |
Removes dissolved salts and most dissolved contaminants |
Yes. |
Moderate to high |
Process water, demineralization, reuse; |
|
BWRO |
RO unit set up to treat brackish water. |
Yes. |
Moderate |
Saline groundwater and groundwater sources for industry |
|
SWRO |
RO set up for seawater |
Yes. |
High |
Seawater desalination |
The BWRO and SWRO are not distinct membrane families in themselves. The operating pressures are different, the type of membrane used varies, the recovery rate varies, the materials differ, and the pretreatment requirements differ due to varying salinity of feed water.
A pressure-driven membrane process that allows the passage of water and dissolved salts but prevents the passage of suspended particles, colloidal matter and many microorganisms, UF is a process. It is suited for use when treating physical contamination, not mineral content.
Examples of its uses include clarification of surface water, tertiary filtration of wastewater, and pretreatment prior to reverse osmosis.
The drawback is that UF does not remove salts from water. If a reduction in conductivity or TDS is required then another process like RO is necessary.
RO is a process that applies hydraulic pressure to force water through a very dense semipermeable membrane at a pressure that exceeds the osmotic pressure. The majority of dissolved salts are rejected to the concentrate stream and lower salinity water is the permeate.
This desalination process is applicable to demineralization applications, to water for the preparation of boiler feed water. Can help to reduce many smaller contaminants and dissolved ions that UF can't handle.
The performance of the RO unit is highly sensitive to the chemistry of feed water. The following can affect operation: hardness, silica, organics, chlorine, suspended solids, pH, temperature, and scaling potential. Pretreatment, therefore, is not added as a package but is determined by the water that is fed into the system.
The salinity of brackish water is in between fresh water and seawater. These include mineralized groundwater, coastal aquifers with salt intrusion, and inland wells with high dissolved solids.
For these lower salinity feeds, BWRO employs RO membranes that are chosen for those feeds. Normally, brackish water has a lower osmotic pressure than seawater and will therefore not need as great an operating pressure as SWRO. The difference impacts the pump selection, power requirement, membrane configuration, and recovery.
QILEE provides a range of brackish-water treatment systems (QL-BWRO) that combine the pretreatment, RO desalination, and post-treatment processes as per project needs.
Seawater is more difficult to treat because of the high salt concentration and the high osmotic pressure. This makes high-pressure operation and membranes suitable for seawater desalination necessary for SWRO systems.
The load in the seawater may also be suspended matter, biological material, organics and changing loads due to intake conditions. Materials that are exposed to saline water should be compatible with it, and the RO stage should be protected from fouling by pretreatment.
In addition, energy use becomes a more significant factor at SWRO pressures. The use of energy-recovery devices has the capacity to recover pressure from the concentrate stream and return some of it to the process, but without altering the principle of membrane separation itself.
The key is the water treatment system supplier's choice of appropriate technology.
The selection process should start with a feed-water condition and then define a product-water specification, and not with a preferred membrane type.
Where turbidity, suspended solids or microorganisms are the primary issue and salts are not considered, UF might be appropriate. RO is suitable for lower conductivity or dissolved-solids reduction. Saline groundwater typically points towards BWRO, and direct seawater treatment requires SWRO engineering.
Design of a system is not solely dependent on flow rate. Because of the difference in the raw-water chemistry of the two plants, the membrane area, pressure, chemical dosing, pretreatment, and recovery strategy may differ to achieve the same volume.
The two treatments—UF and RO—are often used in combination and are sometimes compared as alternatives. The objective of the UF is to first remove the suspended and colloidal material, followed by the removal of dissolved salts in the RO.
This solution works well in the case of variable surface water, reusing wastewater or other feeds that would have a higher fouling load in direct RO operation. The value lies in assigning each membrane the separation task it is suited to, rather than letting one stage do all the water-quality control.
Define the source water and finished-water target prior to requesting equipment. The desired specifications should include flow rate, operating time, feed water analysis, desired conductivity and/or desired TDS, use of the permeate, available power, space limitations and the limitations of the concentrate discharge.
Careful attention is needed to recovery rate. Raising recovery will decrease the amount of reject water but will also increase salt concentration in reject water and possibly increase the risk of scaling. The practical target depends on the water chemistry and system design and is not the same percentage for every project.
Unfortunately, there is no one-size-fits-all best membrane. UF will remove suspended and colloidal contamination but will not desalinate. The main difference is that RO removes dissolved salts, whereas BWRO and SWRO modify the RO process to deal with brackish water and seawater, respectively.
The process should match the feed-water parameters, the finished water parameters, pressure, recovery, pretreatment, and operating conditions and must be matched by a qualified water treatment system supplier or water treatment system manufacturer. When the above-described factors aren't met in a standard configuration, then a custom water treatment system is typically the more technically viable solution.
Consider QILEE water treatment systems for UF, RO, BWRO, SWRO and integrated membrane equipment (IME), and compare system configurations based on the actual water source and water treatment objective.
Tel: +86 13370035529
Business What's App: +86 13636655908
E-mail: qilee@qileegroup.com
Add: No. 351 Wenqu Road, Fengxian District, Shanghai